BOSTON, July 15 /PRNewswire/ --
The following was released today by Hill & Barlow:
In a landmark decision, U.S. District Court Judge Douglas
Woodlock has entered summary judgment in favor of all mentally
retarded adults who have been deemed eligible for Medicaid
services by the Commonwealth of Massachusetts' Department of
Mental Retardation, but who have been placed on a waiting list
for those services for many years, or in some cases, even
decades.
Judge Woodlock found that the Commonwealth failed to provide
services with reasonable promptness as required by the federal
Medicaid Act and has ordered the state to provide services to
those on the waiting list within 90 days. The decision, which is
the first of its kind in the nation to order a state to provide
community-based residential services to eligible mentally
retarded adults within 90 days, means that the Commonwealth will
have to serve approximately 2,600 individuals who are now
believed to be on the waiting list.
The class-action lawsuit (Boulet, et al v. Cellucci) was
filed on March 19, 1999 by the families of five mentally
retarded adults against the Governor of Massachusetts, the
Commonwealth's Secretary of the Executive Office of
Administration and Finance, the Commonwealth's Secretary of the
Executive Office of Health and Human Services, the Commissioner
of the Department of Mental Retardation, and the Commissioner of
the Division of Medical Assistance based on the failure of these
individuals, in their official capacities, to ensure that
mentally retarded and developmentally disabled adults receive
the Medicaid services for which they are eligible under the
federal Medicaid Act and the Commonwealth's Medicaid Program.
"This decision is a victory for the thousands of
families who have dedicated their lives to caring for their
mentally retarded children, but who now urgently need the
state's help," commented Neil McKittrick, an attorney from
the law firm of Hill & Barlow who represented the plaintiffs
on a pro-bono basis. "The parents and caregivers of this
class, many of whom are in their sixties and seventies, have
cared for their adult children in their own homes for 30 or 40
years, saving the Commonwealth millions of dollars. This
decision forces the Commonwealth to live up to its legal
obligation to provide Medicaid services to these people now, not
years from now."
In his decision, Judge Woodlock concluded that the state had
in fact "recognized that those individuals on the waiting
list ... need the services for which they are waiting." He
added that, " ... where some of the delays extend more than
a decade, I have little trouble finding that the defendants have
not been reasonably prompt ... "
Theresa Varnet, Board President of ARC Massachusetts
(formerly the Association for Retarded Citizens) and a parent of
a mentally retarded adult child, stated that, "This
decision offers families peace of mind. We now know that, when
needed, the state will provide appropriate services. We are so
grateful to Hill & Barlow for taking on this case; the
decision will make such a difference to thousands of families
across the state."